HomeRecommended cameras and lensesRecommended accessoriesBest low-light lenses for SonyLens Reviews'A' mount lens chartLens accessories reviews and lens comparisons page'E' system page'E' mount lens chartQuick lens evaluation pageSony/Minolta AF lens price guideSony DSLR/SLT pageFAQs pageFlashes etcMiscellaneousAboutContactUseful links

 
 
 

2012/snfishbox.jpg
Box and contents

 
 
The Sony NEX-C3 was used for this review.  For a better understanding of terms and methods used in this review, go here.
 
 
The usual center, mid-section and corner crops are located at the very bottom of the page.
 
 
 
Introduction.
 
Sony designed the NEX 16mm F/2.8 pancake lens to be compatible with a couple of different converters, the ultra wide angle 0.75x, and the fisheye 0.62x.  This converter gives you approximately a 180° view, but it's not quite as 'wide' as the Vivitar or Rokinon 7mm fisheye lens, also reviewed here.
 
The made in Japan converter uses the focusing of the 16mm host lens, so there are no contacts for communication with the camera, and the EXIF data displays 16mm, so the camera doesn't know it's mounted.
 
Fit and finish: the same as other Sony NEX lenses.  It seems like Sony is using the same outer 'aluminum alloy' material, and the color matches the silver lenses perfectly.  The converter comes with a built-in hood, and can't be removed.
 
The front and rear covers are non-traditional for Sony lenses; they're just plastic covers the fit snugly in place.
 
Light loss when using the converter is approximately a half stop, so the minimum equivalent aperture would be around F/3.2-3.5.
 
Mounting.  The converter mounts to the front of the 16mm lens just outside of the filter threads.  You can mount it upside down if you want, meaning the same as a bayonet type hood.  It doesn't seem to make any difference in image quality.  There is a red dot on the converter that you match up with a red dot on top of the lens, that way you don't have to worry about mounting it wrong.
 


Requisite product shots.

2012/snfishft.jpg
Bulbous front element with built in hood
2012/snfishbk.jpg
Back side, no contacts
2012/snfishcam.jpg
Mounted on Sony NEX-C3 with 16mm pancake lens

 
 
General information and specifications.

Lens

Sony NEX VCL-ECF1  fisheye 0.62x.

Box contents

Front cover, rear cover, clam-shell carrying case and users manual.

Cost

Approximately $110

Build quality

Very good

Additional information

Introduced in 2010.

Specifications below

 

Optical configuration

4 elements in 4 groups, multi-coated.

Angle of view

180°.  0.62x the host lens, 10mm APS-C, 15mm in full frame or 135 film format.

Aperture

N/A

Full frame and APS-C

For NEX 16/2.8 lens only. 

Depth of field and focus scales?

N/A

Minimum focus, image plane to subject

About 5.25"  (133mm)

Minimum focus, end of lens barrel to subject

About 2"  (50mm) distance is from longest hood protrusion.

Hard stop at infinity focus?

No

Length changes when focusing?

N/A

Focus ring turns in AF?

N/A

Filter size

Will not accept filters.

Filter ring rotates?

No

Distance encoder?

No
 

Max magnification

About .078x, or 1:13

Min. F/stop

N/A 

Sony teleconverter compatible?

No

Length changes when zooming?

N/A

Dimensions WxL  (my measurements)

2.6" x 1.57"   66mm x 40mm.  

Maximum  extended length (my measurements)

N/A                                                 

Weight bare (my scale)

5.3oz  (150g)  

 
 
Optical qualities summary.
 
 
Lens flare/ghosting.  Fair to good control.  I see some small multi-colored ghosts and dots, when the sun is near or inside the image.
 
Vignetting or light fall-off is not an issue.  Due to the massive coverage of this lens, you'll experience natural light fall-off when the sun is in the sky. 

Color fringing (CA).  Lateral color fringing control is below average.  Expect color fringing (magenta and cyan) all along the sides of the image.  See sample farther down the page.
 
Bokeh.  The same as the host lens.  Don't worry about background blur with this lens, unless you focus on something very close with a large aperture.
 
Color.   Same as other Sony lenses.
 
Close up filter.  N/A    
 
Coma.  Small amount in the extreme corners, the same as the host lens.
 
Regular filters cannot be used, and there is no rear gel slot.  
 
Filter size.  N/A
 
Distortion example directly below.
 

2012/snfishdis.jpg
Massive distortion; by design!

 
This is part of the fun when using a fisheye lens, it's supposed to distort.
 
 

 

Color fringing.

 

2012/snfishcf11.jpg
Strong color fringing, F/11

 
This 100% crop comes from the bottom left of the image, taken at F/11.  Magenta or red is very noticeable, but I also see plenty of cyan on the opposite.
 

 
 
Conclusion
 
The Sony VCL-ECF1 is a cool little add-on lens for people wanting a fisheye experience using the Sony NEX system.  While this converter is not an optical masterpiece, it actually works well, and can be very fun if you know how to use it.  It's not for 'getting it all in' in a general sense, so don't use it simply as you would a wide angle lens. 
 
Check out my boring Sony 16/2.8 fisheye review for ideas, or Flickr for interesting fisheye compositions, some good, some bad.
 
 

Sample crops from the centers, mid-sections and corners.

 

 

          Center

          Mid-section

             Corner

F/2.8

2012/snfishctrf28.jpg
2012/snfishmidf28.jpg
2012/snfishcornerf28.jpg

F/4

2012/snfishctrf40.jpg
2012/snfishmidf40.jpg
2012/snfishcornerf40.jpg

F/5.6

2012/snfishctrf56.jpg
2012/snfishmidf56.jpg
2012/snfishcornerf56.jpg

F/8

2012/snfishctrf80.jpg
2012/snfishmidf80.jpg
2012/snfishcornerf80.jpg

F/11

2012/snfishctrf11.jpg
2012/snfishmidf11.jpg
2012/snfishcornerf11.jpg

 

Clearly visible here are the soft, wide open results, especially as you move away from the center.  As you stop down the aperture, the image sharpens up, but the corners are mushy at all apertures.  The centers and mid-sections peak around F/5.6, and the corners at F/8-11.  I'd save F/2.8 for low-light shooting when you absolutely need it.

 

That's it, please check out the Sony NEX VCL-ECF1 fisheye converter 0.62x at B&H Photo and help support the site!